Introduction
An
expanding
business offers the potential for numerous growth opportunities.
Employees benefit from business growth through increased earnings and
promotions. Customers benefit from expanded products and services.
Owners benefit through increased profit potential. Society benefits
through the new jobs created. Managing this growth, although
rewarding, can challenge your skills and financial resources.
Financial
management involves all the activities that enable a company to
obtain capital for growth, allocate resources efficiently, maximize
the income potential of the business activity and monitor results
through accounting documents. Such management requires a
well-written, comprehensive financial management plan clearly
outlining the assets, debts and the current and future profit
potential of your business.
This
publication
discusses the how to approach to financial management (i.e., a method
that makes the growth process easier to understand and implement), in
addition to providing general information on the challenge of
managing financial growth. It is divided into three sections, with
each focusing on important aspects of financial management:
Section
1:
Obtaining Capital for Growth;
Section
2:
Managing Capital and
Section
3:
Documenting Results.
Successfully
managing financial resources is important in new and expanding
businesses, so take time to develop and implement a financial plan
that will ensure the success of your business.
Managing
Financial
Growth
Managing
the
finances of a growing business requires persistence and balance. To
obtain the funding needed to finance growth, you must understand the
roles of these concepts and how to apply them in managing a growing
business. A brief discussion of these concepts follows.
Persistence
In
a growing
business, financial resources are often viewed as the major factor
limiting growth potential. There are two methods of improving your
financial base: (1) grow gradually and allow profits to fund
additional growth and (2) seek outside funds (i.e., debt or equity
funding). Either approach will consume time and energy, and you will
experience some rejections. This is where persistence is important.
Your determination, combined with a willingness to adjust your plans,
will carry you through this process. Sustained growth puts stress on
you and the financial resources of your business. Achieving growth
goals often takes longer than you initially planned. However, you are
not alone in the quest for growth and expansion. Many successful
business owners have experienced the same problems and frustrations.
To understand the challenge ahead, visit successful local business
owners and read articles or books about their experiences. Inc., the
Financial Review and some of the general business publications, such
as Business Week, etc., all contain stories about successful growing
businesses. The business section in your local newspaper features
local success stories. Also, area development corporations and
Chambers of Commerce are excellent sources of information on local
businesses. Don't hesitate to take advantage of these resources. You
can learn valuable techniques and concepts that will enable you to
avoid many of the problems other business owners have encountered.
Balance
The
financial
and operational aspects of growth must be balanced when you expand
your business. During a growth phase, for example, the marketing
function of the business may extend beyond the business's financial
capacity to sustain growth. To avoid this dilemma, devise policies to
balance the operational functions of the business with the financial
aspects of growth. Here are several guidelines to help you balance
the finances of a growing business.
- Growth should be attempted only in businesses that are already
profitable. To attain profit potential, a balance must be maintained
between asset and liability items that are on the balance sheet and
operating items that are on the expense and income reports. For
example, if accounts receivable on a balance sheet average $50,000
and sales average $500,000 per year, a balance of 10 percent exists
between these items. If growth is obtained in part by offering easier
credit terms, the balance could be altered if the accounts receivable
average $150,000 and are used to support sales of $1,000,000. Thus,
the balance needed to maintain a profit has been altered. When growth
is undertaken, profit will be negatively affected, at least
initially.
- The existing debt position of the business must be balanced with
equity, or additional equity must be obtained to balance future debt.
The rule of thumb is for the equity position on a balance sheet,
expressed as equity divided by assets, to range from 30 to 50
percent. If your business has an equity position of less than 30
percent and you wish to obtain financing for growth, a certain amount
of money will have to be injected as equity to finance additional
debt.
- Management skills and abilities must be balanced with the
increasing demands on management in a growing business.
There
are
several simple examples of balancing opposing forces that can be
applied to business. One example is the financial management concept.
Financial management compares your company's growth potential when
financing the entire growth phase by reinvesting profits to financing
through an infusion of cash from outside sources. The latter option
accelerates growth; it follows the concept of leverage and allows you
to use equity to obtain additional money so the business can grow
faster. For example, if you can use a 33-percent equity position and
invest $100,000 in a business, you can borrow $200,000 for a total
investment of $300,000. This allows the business to grow faster than
using only the $100,000.
When
accelerating growth, the financial leverage concept works only as
long as the business is profitable or the return on investment
exceeds the debt expense. When this happens, the rate of return
received on the equity investment is greater. For example, if you
invested only the $100,000 and did not borrow any additional money,
the rate of return might be 10 percent. However, if you used the
$100,000 to obtain $200,000, and if the debt is 12 percent and you
make a return of 15 percent on the entire project, the resulting rate
of return on the $100,000 is higher. The 3 percent made on the debt
results in a total dollar value of $6,000. The 15 percent made on the
existing equity (which would be $15,000), combined with the $6,000
made on the debt would result in a final return rate of 21 percent on
the equity portion.
Profitability
is
important to business growth because it makes it easier to obtain the
financing needed to expand. This is the opposite of how accounting
systems are normally operated for tax purposes. To reduce taxes,
accountants and business owners often try to show a loss or as little
profit as possible, which allows the business to retain more cash.
From this standpoint, perhaps your business should be profitable for
several years before initiating a growth phase. In many cases,
however, you will not or cannot take the time to accomplish
consistent profitability. If you are planning to expand your
business, discuss this process with the accountant who prepares your
income statements or taxes in order to legitimately transfer forward
some of your current operating expenses, thus increasing your current
profits.
Other
Considerations
The
time you
spend preparing for growth can also improve your business in several
other areas, including management. Therefore, you should not
implement growth procedures without thoroughly examining all aspects
of your business operations. Listed below are several factors you
should consider before initiating a growth plan.
- Expect that your personal involvement and commitment to the
business will increase during a growth cycle.
- Consider personal sacrifices and the sacrifices of people you
associate with, including family. The rewards of growth can be
substantial and, thus, are deemed adequate rewards for these
sacrifices.
- Expect additional pressure on the time and resources needed to run
the business, because it will take time and energy to organize the
financial aspects of growth.
Before
initiating a growth phase, be sure you have the time, adequate
personnel and financial resources to complete the process.
There
Is No One
Right Way
Before
you look
at the different categories of financial management for a growing
company, remember there is no one right way or easy method. Accept
that you operate in a world of uncertainty, in which decisions often
are made without complete knowledge of all the consequences. This
approach can make managing a growing business challenging and
rewarding.
When
financing a
growth cycle, seek assistance from professionals who know the
process. Assistance is available through consultants, accountants and
lawyers and through services provided by the government.
Obtaining
Capital
for Growth
Deciding
To
Actively Pursue Growth
A
primary reason
for pursuing growth is to increase profit. There are two components
that can be increased the absolute dollar amounts of sales or the
profit as a percentage of sales. If these two can be achieved
simultaneously, the resulting growth will be very rewarding. A more
careful decision process must be completed in situations where there
is a tradeoff, such as between decreasing the percentage of profit to
sales (through reducing prices) or increasing the dollar volume of
sales (through increasing prices).
Reducing
prices
to achieve growth is a strategy you might not initially plan but must
do to sustain growth after commitments have been made. By charging
lower prices to increase sales, you usually decrease the gross profit
margin. However, lower prices may result in significant increases in
the purchase quantity, which then enables the business to earn a
profit. The same concept, only reversed, can apply to costs. For
example, if you increase costs in order to increase dollar sales
volume, you still decrease your profit margin. This latter approach
is feasible if you plan to increase marketing expenditures to gain
additional business.
Costs
also can
be increased from an accounts receivable standpoint. A new business
activity might increase sales by adding customers with poor credit
ratings, thus resulting in a higher accounts receivable cost. Many
managers of unprofitable businesses believe the solution to their
problem is to grow in order to spread fixed costs over a larger
number of units, thereby improving the gross margin of the business.
(A detailed explanation of this concept is provided in the section
Determining the Break-even Point.)
Understanding
Financial Statements
The
balance
sheet, income projection statement and the monthly cash flow
projection of funds are the statements used to manage and report a
business's financial operation. The balance sheet and income
statement will be explained in this section. The cash statement is
not always completed as the checking account register provides the
same information except that it isn't summarized by categories.
The
balance
sheet and income statement contain meaningful information about the
business. The balance sheet indicates the value of the business at a
given point in time and is usually prepared for the end of a typical
reporting (or accounting) period. The income statement covers a
period of time (month, quarter, year) and indicates the level of
profit or loss based on sales less expenses. (Examples of a balance
sheet and income statement are included in Appendix A.)
Balance
Sheet
The
balance
sheet provides a summary of the owner's net worth at a given time.
The first section, labeled assets, usually appears on the left side
or at the top of the statement and includes the business's assets in
declining order of liquidity. The right side or lower portion lists
the liabilities and the owner's equity or net worth. Liabilities
include all commitments or contractual agreements to be paid in the
future. Examples of liabilities include loan principal balances and
accounts payable (money owed for goods or services already received).
The owner's equity is the asset value that actually belongs to the
owner. In a corporation, this is usually divided into original
capital and retained earnings. The capital assets (i.e., equipment
and buildings) are valued at their original cost minus any
depreciation that has been taken in the past. This results in a
book-value balance sheet, because the real value of capital items
could be more or less than this calculation indicates.
Note
that on the
balance sheet the total assets equal the total liabilities plus the
owner's equity. The owner's equity position is the relationship
between the total assets and the total liabilities. In the sample
balance sheet in Appendix A, the equity position is a percentage,
28.3 percent, that is calculated by dividing the owner's equity
($57,945) by the total assets ($204,945).
Income
Statement
The
income
statement (sometimes called profit and loss statement) brings
together the income generated and expenses incurred from business
activity over a specified period of time. This time period can be a
month, a quarter, a year or the year-to-date.
The
difficulty
in developing an income statement is in allocating certain costs to
the period of time covering the statement. One example is
depreciation. Many fixed assets, such as equipment and building
costs, cannot be included under expenses. To allocate these costs
properly, their purchase price must be divided by the expected life
in years or months, whichever corresponds to the period covered by
the income statement. Using the straight-line method of calculating
depreciation, their purchase price is charged uniformly over the life
of the assets. However, the depreciation rate often is accelerated
for income tax purposes.
Another
difficulty in cost allocations are loans in which payments are
divided into interest and principal components. Only interest is
included on the income statement; it is treated like a rent or lease
payment. The principal is neither income when a loan is received nor
an expense when it is paid back.
The
balance
sheet and income statement are related to each other. Your equity on
the beginning balance sheet plus the profit (or minus the loss) from
the income statement equals your equity for that period. Profit needs
to be adjusted for any withdrawals that are not expenses, such as
payment of the loan principal or income tax.
Developing
Projections
The
first step
in undertaking growth is to develop projected income statements, cash
flow statements and balance sheets. All potential lenders require
these projections before approving loans. These estimates also can be
used to help you decide whether to seek outside funding, even though
this decision may seem obvious based on your current market
activities.
These
projection
statements, sometimes called pro forma statements, should be
developed for at least one year and perhaps two to five years into
the future. (Examples of pro forma statements are included in
Appendix B. Blank forms are included in Appendix C.) You may wonder:
How can I know what will happen? To answer this question, divide the
projections into steps. The most critical step is balancing costs to
sales in order to determine a profit margin.
Profit
margins
for income projections should always be reasonable, especially if
outside financing is used. If the first years of the projections show
a loss, it will be difficult to convince potential investors to
invest in your business. If, however, the projections show excessive
profits, potential investors may feel the project is unrealistic.
This means that your figures must be fairly conservative.
What
is a
reasonable profit margin? It is a profit margin that is in line with
the profit margins of the industry. For example, $80,000 on a
projected income statement is a reasonable before tax profit margin
in the following case. First, all income tax is subtracted at an
estimated rate of 25 percent, leaving $60,000. You quit a job that
paid $40,000 to start this business; therefore, you maintain this
salary as being consistent with your personal living expenses. This
leaves $20,000 of profit. The next step is to compare the remaining
profit to the amount of equity invested or the amount of your equity
on the current balance sheet. For this example, we will assume the
equity level is $200,000. The profit of $20,000 is divided by the
equity of $200,000, which results in a 10 percent rate of return.
This rate of return is reasonable for a growing business; however,
the rate of return could increase in the future because of the growth
process. Phenomenal rates of return, such as 100 to 1,000 percent or
higher, are possible in smaller businesses. (See Inc.'s list of the
100 fastest growing companies.) Even though this is possible, the
rate of return should be conservative on a projection.
Deciding
the
rate at which your company should grow is challenging and demands
flexibility. Flexibility can be difficult if you already have a
preconceived idea of the growth level you want. Your idea may exceed
the capacity of the business's management and equity positions. It is
helpful to develop several projections because different levels of
growth will have different investment requirements and profit
results. For example, if a business is expected to grow to $500,000
in sales per year, you may be able to continue renting a facility.
However, if the business is expected to grow to $800,000 in sales per
year, a new facility may be required and its cost will affect the
projected profit. The same can be true with items of equipment, which
also depend on the relationship between the short and long-term
potential. The addition of a new building can have a short-term,
negative impact on profitability, but it also can result in an
improved profit margin for the business within three to five years.
Because input into a business operation is not always proportional
and can come in steps, completing several projections based on
different options will help determine which projection is best.
Individual
circumstances may require growth to be pursued at a slower pace, yet
you can end up with similar profits. For example, you currently
operate a business with sales of $600,000 per year, and you want the
business to grow to sales of $2 million by the third year. You might
project both of the following growth trends:
Example
A Year
1, $1.0 million, Year 2, $1.5 million, Year 3, $2.0 million,
Example
B Year
1, $1.8 million, Year 2, $1.9 million, Year 3, $2.0 million,,
As
you can see,
the result is the same. Example B illustrates an initial high, fixed
investment, used to support expansion, with slower growth following.
For example, a successful restaurant with sales of $600,000 may build
two more restaurants in different cities and thus triple its total
sales. Example A reflects a situation in which growth is obtained
more gradually by incurring variable costs and reinvesting profits in
the business. For example, a restaurant may attempt to increase its
growth by maintaining the same single location, but adding new
services or additional operating hours.
You
can further
control your growth rate by recognizing that all fixed costs are
variable over time. Strictly speaking, fixed costs are those costs
that are stable for a given period (e.g., one year). However, when
you consider growth over a three- to five-year period, fixed costs
can be treated more like variable costs. For example, alternatives to
purchasing a new, full-size facility may include leasing facilities,
constructing a smaller facility or creating unique distribution
channels.
Computer
spreadsheet programs are excellent to develop projections as they
easily allow what if analysis in determining different levels of
growth. If such programs are not available, seek help from
professionals who provide services to small businesses, such as SBA,
SCORE, SBDCs and SBIs.
The
costs of a
growth cycle can be incurred in blocks or steps. This is especially
true for equipment and buildings; however, it can also apply to
marketing costs. For example, a manufacturing company may have only
one machine that completes a process required of all its products. To
double production capacity, the company must decide between adding a
second shift or adding a second machine. Adding a second machine
doubles costs in the form of depreciation and other operating costs;
adding a second shift doubles personnel costs. Either way, the
company must consider the marketing option of adding a salesperson in
order to increase its sales volume to in turn support higher fixed
costs.
Determining
the
Break-even Point
Break-even
analysis can help you make decisions because it allows you to
visualize the relationships between costs that are spread over time.
Such analysis involves dividing costs into two categories: fixed
costs and variable costs.
Fixed
costs are
those costs that do not vary over a period of time, or generally do
not fluctuate with changes in sales volume. These costs include the
purchase price of buildings and equipment. Variable costs are costs
that vary depending on the time period or the sales volume generated.
These costs usually include the cost of materials purchased for
retail operations and labor costs.
The
textbook
approach to break-even analysis is based on the units of production.
For business activities, it is better to base such analysis on the
dollar volume of sales of the business. Break-even analysis can be
expressed as a dollar amount and can be displayed on a graph. On a
projected income statement, a convenient way of breaking out fixed
costs and variable costs is to treat the cost of goods sold and labor
as variable costs and all other expenses as fixed costs. Below is a
sample income statement:
Sales $100,000
Cost of goods sold $30,000
Wages $20,000
Fixed expenses $40,000
Profit $10,000
The
break-even
point can be calculated as follows. First calculate the contribution
margin, which is defined as the percentage of sales available for use
toward fixed costs and profit. In the above sample income statement,
the variable costs (goods plus wages) are 50 percent of sales, so the
contribution margin is 50 percent. The actual break-even point is the
fixed costs ($40,000) divided by the percentage of sales the variable
costs represent (50 percent), which equals $80,000. At this point,
all fixed costs as well as variable costs are covered. To verify your
answer, multiply 50 percent by $80,000. The answer is the amount of
the fixed costs, or $40,000. The variable cost at this rate is
$40,000 or 50 percent of $80,000.
The
break-even
point can be calculated using different assumptions of what should be
included in the fixed-cost portion. If the business needs to generate
enough profit to pay the owner's wages plus the recovered debt
principal and income tax obligations, these costs should be included
with the fixed-cost amount; thus, the break-even point will be
higher. The break-even sales level usually covers a year; however,
the time increment can be broken down into months, weeks or days. In
the above example, the break-even point of $80,000 is equivalent to
$266 per day (assuming a 300-day work year). This figure should be
set as your average daily goal; however, don't forget to consider
seasonal sales and daily fluctuations as well.
It
is difficult
to assure accurate projections, but if each dollar item in a
projection is carefully considered with regard to the volume or
capacity of the business, the resulting figure should be relatively
accurate. Final income statements tend to show costs higher than what
was projected. If plans are made carefully, the result might be that
profit is very similar to what was projected; but some of the items
will be higher or lower than planned.
In
projecting
income in order to obtain financing, compile figures conservatively.
Bankers know it is very easy to come up with lofty profitability
projections and may discount an application on that basis.
Projections should indicate the ability of the business to pay off
debt while earning a reasonable return on labor and investment.
Decisions
on
whether to grow and the rate at which to grow should be based on the
concept of improved value. Profits can be drawn by the owner or
reinvested in the business where they can increase the asset basis of
the business. A recommended strategy for the owner-manager is to
consider a combination of these options.
Estimating
Expansion Costs
An
important
part of growth is the budget, or the allocation of funds to those
activities that will bring about growth. There is a fine line between
not having enough money and having too much money. The disadvantages
of borrowing too much are (1) the increased interest costs and (2)
exceeding equity limitations. The disadvantage of not borrowing
enough is getting halfway through a project and discovering there are
not enough funds available to complete it. The problem usually
associated with expansion is underestimating costs. The following
sections address the costs of buildings, equipment and inventory and
the cash tied up in accounts receivable and operating capital, as
they relate to estimating expansion costs.
Building
Costs
To
determine the
cost of a building, choose a layout that can be reduced to a
blueprint or a sketch for contractors to bid on. (Many contractors
provide blueprints in conjunction with the bidding process.) After
you have blueprints or a layout, obtain competitive bids from several
contractors. Bids will allow you to compare the abilities of
individual firms to build efficiently and ultimately can help you
achieve lower costs. Be sure the contractors are bidding on identical
specifications and quality. Many construction companies have
specialty projects that may match your company's project, possibly
resulting in a lower price.
If
you do not
know a contractor, check his or her credentials with the bank and
other references, such as customers and suppliers of building
materials. Reputable contractors are accustomed to working under
performance bonds. You should investigate this option. Bonding is a
system in which the contractor promises to complete the work at a
time, quality and price specified in the contract. If the work is not
so completed, the contractor forfeits the bond and the proceeds are
used to reimburse the customer's loss. Bonding is usually handled
through an insurance company. If you request a bond, you should
receive a copy of the agreement directly from the insurance carrier.
Next,
discuss
with the contractors their relationship with subcontractors. Usually
a general contractor will negotiate and work with subcontractors in
the electrical, plumbing, heating, and certain other trades.
Subcontractors are usually coordinated by the general contractor and
complete and invoice their work through the contractor. Should you
choose to directly employ subcontractors, you will be responsible for
coordinating their work. This can reduce costs in some cases. If this
is done, the subcontractors should also be asked to submit a bond for
the work performed. (Also, be sure to check with utility companies to
determine hookup costs and whether deposits are required.)
Scheduling
is
another aspect of construction that should be carefully planned to
reduce costs. Often unknown factors mainly the weather can affect the
schedule. Such factors should be figured into the time allowed for
the construction process, as increased construction time can result
in additional interest charges. It is customary for a construction
contractor to receive periodic payments during a project to cover
costs. The new building owner usually pays 90 percent of the cost of
work completed until the project is done. Thinking through this whole
process in advance will reduce the need for any change in orders,
which can result in additional costs.
Equipment
Costs
New
equipment
purchases often accompany an expansion. Contact several equipment
suppliers to discuss your needs, the capabilities of specific
equipment and prices. Other related expenses associated with
equipment should be investigated, such as delivery, hookups to
utilities, installation costs and unusual operating expenses.
Leasing
should
be considered as an alternative to purchasing equipment. Usually
leases can be obtained from the company that sells the equipment, but
there are also leasing companies and leasing divisions at banks. The
disadvantage to leasing is that the rate usually is higher than the
interest rate for purchasing equipment. The major advantage of a
lease, however, is the low down payment or equity position required
to initiate the lease. Most leases place the responsibility for
repairing equipment with the lessor. This can reduce the risk of
having to incur repair expenses at a time when your cash flow is
tight and repair costs difficult to cover. Be sure you understand all
provisions of the lease agreement. Many companies offer
lease-to-purchase plans that enable you to eventually purchase the
equipment. This can be a viable option.
Delivery
of
equipment, whether new or leased, should be carefully timed with
completion of other construction activities so the equipment is not
sitting idle.
Inventory
Costs
Inventory
is the
product, in its various stages of completion, that is finally sold to
generate revenue and receivables. It is an important aspect of a
company's operating cycle because it is a window into the company,
i.e., it will tell how well the company produces the goods and
services it sells. Inventory should always be valued at the lower
cost or market value to ensure that its value is not overstated on
the balance sheet.
The
level of
inventory in an expanding business should be easy to determine
because it is based on a comparison of past inventory levels to past
sales. The inventory turnover ratio is the cost of goods sold divided
by the average inventory and is the ratio that is often used when a
growth phase is initiated. The cost of new inventory should be
considered because it might be higher than the cost of existing
inventory. It is usually assumed in an expansion process that the
existing inventory can be easily liquidated and, therefore, the
inventory turnover ratio will increase. However, the opposite could
occur if you attempt to increase sales by offering an increased
inventory. Also, it is usually assumed that, as inventory increases,
carrying costs will decrease because of the additional economies of
scale gained with the additional inventory. Again, this should be
carefully determined by investigating actual carrying costs.
Inventory
is
important to both new and expanding business because, before it is
sold and becomes a receivable, it represents invested cash. When
separated into its parts (raw materials, work in process and finished
goods), the inventory cycle will identify lags and structural
difficulties a company has in the production process.
Accounts
Receivable
Like
inventory,
future accounts receivable are projected from the existing
receivables on the balance sheet and are normally in the same
proportion to future sales as current receivables are to current
sales. For example, past sales of $100,000 and accounts receivable of
$5,000 represent a relationship of 5 percent of accounts receivable
to sales. If growth is projected to $500,000, then projected accounts
receivable at 5 percent would be $25,000.
It
is possible
for accounts receivable to increase out of proportion to the existing
figure. For example, accounts receivable could easily be a higher
proportion if, in the process of increasing sales, relationships with
slower paying customers were established. To illustrate this, if
actual accounts receivable average $5,000 when sales are at $100,000,
a variance of 1 percent would result in accounts receivable of
$6,000, a difference of only $1,000. However, at an operating level
of $500,000 sales, a 1 percent negative variance translates into a
$5,000 difference. If this is not planned for, it would be more
difficult for you to come up with $5,000 than it would be to come up
with $1,000.
Estimated
Expansion
Expenses
The
last and
most difficult cost category to project is the additional cash needed
to support increased activity. The best method for calculating this
amount is to use a cash flow projection. Cash flow forms (see cash
flow projection in Appendix B) are available through local SBA,
SCORE, SBDC and SBI offices. To complete the form, distribute the
cash income over the months when the sales growth should occur (cash
expenses are calculated the same way) and then determine the expenses
needed to generate the desired increase in income.
During
a
business expansion, cash balances will normally decrease for a while,
and then show a gain. This gain will occur only if the business is
profitable. It can be difficult to predict when a growth in cash flow
should begin. As a general rule, it should be within the first
operating year, preferably by the third or fourth month; however,
this may vary.
Seasonal
fluctuations in cash receipts and cash expenditures should be built
into the cash flow projection. This will indicate those months cash
should be reserved to cover excess expenses when cash out exceeds
cash in. If the business is profitable and some portion of profit is
reinvested in the business, then the cash flow projection should
account for this as well. The impact of income tax on cash flow also
should be included.
For
each level
of sales volume, a certain residual amount of cash should be retained
in the business. For example, if sales have been $50,000 per year,
the cash balance carried might be $1,000; if sales are at $500,000
per year, the cash amount carried might be $10,000. These amounts are
somewhat arbitrary and depend on the nature of the business; however,
each increase does not have to be proportional to sales. Instead, the
residual cash amount should be based on the cash flow projection for
operating the business.
After
determining cash needs, a certain amount could be budgeted to cover
unexpected contingent liabilities or to compensate for slow turnover
in receivables. Select this figure carefully because investors may be
skeptical if it is too large. It is better to estimate a little
higher on some of the account categories that have definite needs,
thus reducing the need for a large contingency amount.
Purchasing
Another
Business
At
times
expansion can be accomplished by purchasing another business. In this
situation, the expansion costs equal the costs of purchasing the
business plus the amount of money needed for improvements and
operating expenses. Many industries have standard rules that should
be considered on how to determine the purchase price of a business.
Obtaining
Financing
Bank
Requirements
To
obtain bank
financing for your business, the relationship between your company
and the banker should be open and honest. If this is not the case,
perhaps it is time to consider a different bank. When shopping for a
new bank, do not make a decision based upon a particular loan
officer, because this relationship can change if the loan officer is
replaced. Therefore, consider both the relationship with the loan
officer and the relationship with the bank. It is also possible for
your business to grow to the extent it does not fit the capacity of
its existing bank. If this happens, consider establishing a new
relationship with a larger bank that can handle your company's future
needs.
The
first step
in obtaining financing for an expanding business should be to
understand and meet the exact requirements and concerns of the bank.
To avoid risks and make safe investments, bankers primarily base
their decisions on the collateral and equity positions. Other
concerns of a banker include cash flow, profitability and management
ability.
Collateral
Debt
can be
either secured by collateral or covered by a firm's assets. A bank
considers collateral the final alternative (last resort) for
collecting money if payments are not made on loan principal. The
Uniform Commercial Code1 establishes procedures whereby a bank can
seize any collateral pledged in a loan agreement in case of default
on the loan. The value of collateral is usually listed in the asset
section of the balance sheet; its value should always equal or exceed
the amount of the loan.
Often
in a
business start-up, the initial balance sheet will show an adequate
collateral position; however, six months to a year later, the balance
sheet may show a decreased collateral position. One example of this
is getting a loan to purchase a vehicle. The depreciation rate for
the first six months to one year will exceed the amount paid on the
principal. Thus, depreciation is usually computed on an accelerated
basis. If you purchase a vehicle for $20,000 and borrow the full
amount at 10 percent for four years, the monthly payment would be
$507.25 per month. The day you purchased the vehicle and took out the
loan, the collateral value matched the loan amount exactly. If you
use a straight-line rather than an accelerated method of calculating
depreciation, the vehicle will last four years, and cost $5,000 per
year. At the end of the first year, the book value of the vehicle,
which often equals its real market value, is $15,000. However, the
amount owed on the principal at the end of one year is $15,720.36
$720.36 more than the book value. This point clearly illustrates why
banks require a down payment on this type of loan. The down payment
usually ensures that the asset value always exceeds the loan
principal balance.
It
is also
possible to lose collateral in the first years of a business by
borrowing money and then gradually using that money to pay for
expenses (such as utility bills and marketing costs) that do not
result in asset appreciation. For example, if you are planning to
spend $1,000 to have brochures printed, the cash in the bank before
the brochures are printed is good collateral because it can be used
by the bank if you default on the loan. However, once this money is
spent to buy the brochures, the collateral value is much weaker
because the expenditure has value only for your business and cannot
be easily transferred to others.
When
a bank
forecloses on a failing business, it is often unable to recover the
full amount the owner paid for the assets, because of depreciation
and the nature of a force sale. As a result, foreclosure leaves the
banker with assets worth less than the dollar value indicated on your
balance sheet. For these reasons, you can understand why it is easier
to borrow money to buy fixed assets (such as inventory, equipment,
buildings and accounts receivable) than it is to borrow money for
marketing expenses or general operating costs.
Equity
Bankers
also
review the current and projected equity position of a business.
Equity is listed as owner's equity or a combination of capital and
retained earnings. The owner's equity is usually calculated by
subtracting all liabilities from all assets. The important aspect of
equity is not so much the dollar amount but the ratio of equity to
assets or debt.
A
growing
business usually shows an equity position of 30 to 50 percent in
relation to total assets, i.e., the owners own 30 to 50 percent of
the company. Initially, such an equity position may be adequate, but
it may become inadequate when additional money is needed for growth.
Because of the need to maintain the equity ratio in its relative
position, additional equity may need to be brought into the company.
For example, suppose a company's total assets are $100,000; total
debt, $70,000; and owner's equity, $30,000. The equity-to-assets
ratio is 30 percent. For this business to grow to an asset level of
$200,000, the owner needs to provide an additional $30,000 of equity
and then borrow another $70,000 (debt). Ways to bring equity into a
business include
-
Venture
capital funds
-
State and
federal financing programs
-
Private
investment
-
Owner's
personal investment
An
alternative
to obtaining equity is to wait and reinvest the business's profits to
finance the growth.
Cash
Flow
Projections
For
any business
growth cycle, cash flow projections that compare cash receipts and
cash expenses should be completed. Bankers realize that bank loans
are paid from the business's cash flow, so you must convince them
that there is adequate potential to repay the loan. A detailed
explanation of the cash flow projection is included in the section
Effective Cash Flow Management on page 10 or see Instructions for
Cash Flow Projection in Appendix C.
Income
(Profit and
Loss) Projection Statement
The
profit and
loss statement, more commonly known as an income statement, reflects
the dynamic changes that occur over time between two balance sheets.
It reflects the company's operation as a result of management's
efforts to generate a profit. The income statement matches all
revenues with corresponding expenses for a specific period of time
and reports the company's ability to generate profits (excess of
revenues over expenses).
Income
projections should indicate when profitability will occur. Even
though profit and cash flow can be unrelated, the possibility of
having an adequate cash flow definitely increases when a projected
income statement shows a profit. Bankers generally assume that a loan
can be repaid if the business is profitable. The banker's concern in
this process is, Where is the profit going? If the profit is being
reinvested into expansion activities, such as increasing inventory or
marketing expenses, the banker's concern is whether or not loan
payments can still be made. See Appendix C for Instructions for the
Income Projection Statement.
Management
Ability
A
growing
business usually has the advantage over a new business of having
records on past performance that reflect the owner's management
ability. Management and the organization must be flexible to allow
for growth and change. Consider the following question: If growth
occurs, will management be able to handle the new situation? Your
answer should help you determine whether you will need to hire
additional managers or develop current management skills.
Simply
developing and implementing a strategic plan to obtain additional
funding will test management's ability to plan and handle growth. The
activities involved in obtaining needed financing are in themselves a
new challenge to management. Management weaknesses should be
addressed as a part of the growth process.
Personal
Financial
Statement
Usually
banks
will require personal financial statements from all owners. Personal
financial statements are the balance sheets of the business's owners.
They are an important part of a business's financial package because
(1) they verify the company financial statements, (2) they identify
hidden company liability or equity and (3) they reveal other
activities vying for an owner's attention. Strong company financial
statements are generally reflected in strong personal financial
statements; therefore, the stronger an owner's financial statements,
the better his or her chances of obtaining the loan.
Wealth
accumulated on a personal balance sheet is an informal method of
judging an owner's ability to obtain, manage and keep money. Personal
financial statements should not include existing business activities;
these figures should be supplied separately. As indicated above, the
banker is looking at potential collateral and adequate equity.
Market
Value
Balance Sheet
One
of the
problems in a growing business is that the existing equity or
collateral position can be artificially low because of accelerated
depreciation. Using accelerated depreciation results in a book-value
balance sheet that has less equity or collateral than a market-value
balance sheet. The former shows assets at their depreciated value
whereas the latter shows the assets at their current market value.
Thus it may be important to provide a banker with a market-value
balance sheet.
A
typical way to
develop a market-value balance sheet is to present your current book
value balance sheet with an additional column for the market value.
At the bottom of this balance sheet explain each column.
Documentation of market value can be provided through appraisals or
advertisements that include prices on similar equipment or assets.
The market-value balance sheet usually increases the equity dollar
amounts and the equity-to-assets ratio. This should result in a
banker's willingness to loan a larger amount for growth activities.
Business
Plan
A
business plan
is the blueprint or road map for the owners to successfully carry out
growth in a business. This plan communicates the intentions of the
owner to others and can be used to obtain financing. The content of
the business plan is determined by the planning process itself, and
includes research documenting growth potential. Business plans
include
-
Cash flow
projections
-
Income
statements and balance sheets with a detailed narrative of how growth
must be attained
-
Justification
for numbers used in financial statements
Details
on
writing a business plan can be found in many sources. See the outline
of How to Write a Business Plan in Appendix E.
Other
State
Financing
State
financial
programs are also available to small business owners who need
financing. Most programs are justified by the economic development
and the jobs created within the state by the business. At times these
programs can take a second mortgage position compared to banks or
other sources of debt and can charge lower interest rates. Many state
programs have special programs for women, minorities or manufacturing
businesses.
Managing
Capital
Effective
Cash Flow
Management
Cash
flow
analysis shows whether your daily operations have generated enough
cash to meet your obligations, and if major cash outflows combine
with major cash inflows to form a positive cash flow or a net drain.
Any significant changes over time will also appear in this analysis.
It
is extremely
important to have enough cash on hand each month to pay the cash
obligations of the following month. A monthly cash flow projection
helps to project funds and compare actual figures to those of past
months and enables you to eliminate cash deficiencies or surpluses.
Cash flow deficiencies indicate a need to alter plans to provide more
cash. Cash surpluses may indicate excessive borrowing or idle money
that could be invested. Cash itself does not create new income for
the business. Therefore, the cash account balance on a balance sheet
actually should be small relative to other assets. The object is to
develop a plan that will provide a well-balanced cash flow.
Cash
flow
analysis establishes a budget for the cash requirements for the
business. During stable business conditions, there is little need to
develop a budget because future business activity can be predicted
from past trends. For growing businesses, the relationship between
sales and expenses changes, thus establishing the need for a cash
flow projection. The cash flow projection indicates a flow of
dollars; therefore, if dollar amount changes early in the year, it is
going to affect the remaining months by the same amount.
Understanding cash flow and how it is computed is a very important
part of cash flow projections.
SBA
has an
excellent cash flow form (See Appendix B). The SBA's version is a
simplified form; it allows for only one sales entry and one accounts
receivable entry per month. Completing this form will enable you to
compute projections correctly, and better understand the relationship
of cash flow in the finances of a company. This form is available at
SBA area offices and through SCORE chapters and SBDCs.
Unfortunately,
cash flow management is often limited to keeping track of the
checkbook balance. The problem with relying on this system is that it
can result in your using cash that should be reserved for something
else. Some practical steps can be taken to improve your ability to
manage cash flow, especially during the changes brought about by
growth. These include
-
Collecting
receivables
-
Tightening
credit requirements
-
Increasing
sales
-
Pricing
products
-
Securing loans
If
your company
has multiple divisions, products or locations, develop individual
cash flows and then consolidate them to determine the complete cash
flow picture. The SBA form has a column for actual results in
addition to the estimated column. This allows you to record what you
actually have spent and compare it against the estimate. A cash flow
projection is usually computed on a yearly basis. To compensate for
changes occurring after the projection, it is advisable to update it
periodically to determine if there will be a detrimental effect
later. If your company's new area of growth is an activity that is
seasonal, i.e., opposite the current season, the cash flow projection
will help determine the combined impact.
In
a cash flow
statement it is important that all sales and expenses listed for a
particular month are balanced. To compensate for situations in which
expenses are due at the first of the month but revenue does not come
in until the end of the month, complete a daily or weekly cash flow
statement. Another way to compensate in these situations is to change
your month's beginning and ending dates; for example, go from the
15th of the current month to the 15th of the next month. This will
resolve the problem because it will ensure that one month's cash from
sales arrives before expenses are due.
Computer
spreadsheet programs can be extremely helpful for computing cash flow
projections. They allow for what if analysis, which provides several
possible outcomes. If you have the software, you can design your own
spreadsheet, or you can get templates from business service
providers.
Good
accounting
records and good projections are important tools for a small
business. Qualified accountants are necessary to help keep your
records accurate and current. However, you can reduce your accounting
expenses by producing your own summary statistics and projections.
With the help of a personal computer and a good financial management
plan, you can successfully project future activity and use the what
if analysis to test various management decisions.
Cash
Flow Versus
Income Projections
One
of the major
distinctions between cash flow and income projections is that the two
can appear unrelated. The differences result from how principal
payments and depreciation are recorded. Loan principal payments are
included as cash outflow but are not recorded on the income
statement. On the other hand, depreciation is included as a business
expense of the income statement but not as cash outflow.
In
a business in
which sales are growing, the inventory and accounts receivable are
also probably growing. These different areas of growth can affect the
income and cash flow. For example, if inventory increases during the
year, the dollar amount used to purchase materials will increase, and
thus the cash flow or available cash will decrease. This can cause an
inadequate cash level during a slow period. A similar situation can
occur with accounts receivable. If accounts receivable increase, then
expenditures to provide services to customers will increase, but
there will be no incoming cash to cover these increased costs. The
accounts receivable, inventory and cash-on-hand amounts are all
represented on a business's balance sheet.
In
a growing
business in which the accounts receivable and inventory are fairly
constant, the cash flow should be adequate if the business is
operating profitably. In this situation, any depreciation amounts
should be retained for future expansion, and profits should be used
to retire the loan principal. Such a strategy is important for a
growing business. If depreciation and money from accounts receivable
are used for operating cash flow, this can result in a lower equity
position, making it difficult to borrow money to replace worn-out
assets.
Borrowing
Money
Loans
from
various financial institutions are often necessary for covering
short-term cash flow problems. Revolving credit lines and equity
loans are common types of credit used in this situation. Short-term
borrowing works fine as long as everything goes well. However, if
your business experiences a downturn in volume, short-term borrowing
can cause a bank to call in a loan or cancel its credit line, leaving
your business without adequate operating cash.
Long-term
loans
amortized monthly can improve a business's operating cash position.
Amortized monthly means the monthly payment is constant and includes
interest and principal portions that change in proportion as the loan
is paid off. During the early stages of the loan, the interest
portion is high and the principal is low; however, this situation
reverses itself over the life of the loan.
In
a situation
in which long-term debt is used and the business has a seasonal peak
demand, the excess cash should be invested in easily accessible,
interest-bearing, low-risk accounts, such as savings accounts, a
short-term certificate of deposit or a Treasury note (commonly called
a T-bill). The money should not be used for cash operating expenses
or to avoid a shortfall when cash is needed. Keeping excess cash on
hand reduces both the growth and the return on investment.
Tax
Obligations
Income
and
payroll tax obligations can also affect cash flow. If a business is
profitable and growing, the cash that should be retained for income
tax payment and payroll tax can easily be spent for other items that
support growth. This results in a cash shortage when income taxes are
due. To avoid this shortage, make adequate projections and analyze
current income statements to determine future tax obligations. As
these obligations are determined, cash should be set aside to meet
them.
Managing
Credit
The
credit a
company extends to its customers can be crucial in its impact on cash
flow if the customers do not pay on time. New businesses and growing
businesses often do not have the advantage of previous experience
with their customers and can find themselves extending credit to
high-risk customers. Research should be done in advance to determine
a customer's ability to pay bills on time. Methods of determining
this include obtaining a copy of a Dun & Bradstreet report on a
potential customer and requiring potential customers to complete a
credit application that asks questions about the business's ability
to pay. References should be checked to get others' perceptions of
customers and their integrity. (There are several publications
available through the Government Printing Office that discuss credit.
Complying With the Credit Practices Rule and How to Write Readable
Credit Forms are both published by the Trade Commissions and are
available through the Government Printing Offices.
When
working in
a business activity that sells directly to customers, it is advisable
not to extend store credit but to use charge cards. Information on
offering credit card purchases can be obtained through your company's
bank. Banks charge businesses different rates for credit card sales,
based on the dollar volume of the sales, so check several bank
sources. The disadvantage of the credit card is it costs you a
specified percentage, ranging from 2 to 5 percent, of the total
dollar volume customers charge. On the other hand, customers often
expect the convenience of credit cards.
As
credit and
terms are tightened, more customers will pay cash for their
purchases, thereby increasing your cash on hand and reducing your
potential for a bad debt expense. While tightened credit is helpful
in the short run, it may not be advantageous in the long run. Looser
credit allows customers more opportunity to purchase your products or
services. Just be certain the increase in sales is greater than the
increase in bad debt expenses.
Discounts
for Early
Payment
The
practice of
receiving cash discounts for early payment illustrates a major
difference between the cash flow and projected income statements. Not
taking advantage of a cash discount by paying bills promptly can
improve your immediate cash flow, but can also negatively affect
profitability. On the other hand, by paying early, your costs will be
lower and profit margin higher, but your cash flow could be strained.
Certainly a business should consider taking advantage of discounts,
but should also know when and how to capitalize on them. Your company
might also consider offering these discounts to help its cash flow.
Increasing
Sales
Increasing
sales
appears to increase cash flow, but be careful. For many companies, a
large portion of sales are purchased on credit. Therefore, when sales
increase, accounts receivable, not cash, increase. Receivables are
usually collected 30 days after the purchase date. Sales expenses are
most often incurred before receivables are collected. When sales
rise, inventory is depleted and must be replaced. Because receivables
have not yet been collected, a substantial increase in sales can
quickly deplete a firm's cash reserves. With a computer, you can
monitor this critical data and increase the time required to consider
alternate what if scenarios.
Techniques
for
Reducing Costs
Techniques
for
reducing costs will be discussed in two sections: the first suggests
methods for reducing the cost of normal operations and the second
shows how to evaluate and deal with risks that can increase costs.
Analyzing
Your
Costs
Determining
Highest
Costs
All
expense
categories on an income statement should be reviewed to identify
opportunities to reduce expenses. The first place to look for cost
reduction opportunities is those cost categories highest as a
percentage of sales this is often the cost of sales (COS). For
example, if COS is 50 percent of sales, a 10-percent reduction in
this category will result in a 5-percent reduction in overall costs.
This can be compared with some of the fixed costs in the operation,
such as interest, rent or depreciation costs, which are often in the
area of 5 to 10 percent of sales. If you reduce an expense item that
is only 10 percent of sales by 10 percent, you only reduce your
overall expenses by 1 percent. Determining your highest costs can
guide you on how to allocate time and resources toward cost
reductions and will result in a substantial decrease in costs.
Buying
Groups
Often
small
businesses have trouble purchasing goods at a discounted price
because they do not have the volume buying power of larger companies.
One method of reducing purchasing costs is to join or create buying
groups of like businesses that purchase the same products but are not
in direct competition with one another. This type of relationship can
result in quantity discounts and a better selection of merchandise.
Inventory
Inventory
has
several associated costs in addition to its purchase price. This is
true for raw materials, work in process, finished goods and
retail/wholesale inventory. If inventory can be reduced and sales
maintained, the result will have a positive impact on profitability.
The
inventory
turnover ratio is a good measure of the relationship between
inventory and sales. This ratio is calculated by dividing the cost of
sales by the average inventory for that period of time. A high ratio
normally indicates an efficient use of inventory. However, a high
ratio can also mean you are missing sales opportunities because items
that customers are requesting are not in stock. The proper
relationship must be determined for each situation.
Inventory
carrying costs usually include interest, storage, insurance,
obsolescence, physical damage and deterioration. These costs can be
reduced by applying just-in-time inventory and manufacturing
techniques. For a manufacturer, just-in-time techniques involve
structuring the flow of materials through the plant to reduce
inventory in all categories. The benefit of this technique is that it
reduces holding costs. Just-in-time inventory results in better
management and scheduling of both raw materials coming into the plant
and inventory leaving the plant. These techniques are usually
associated with manufacturing but can also be applied to
retail/wholesale businesses.
Use
Contracts
If
business
activity is generated by contracts, consider negotiating the payment
time as well as the price. This technique will improve overall cash
flow. It also will affect expenses because less cash is needed to
carry the activities of the business, thus reducing interest costs.
Instead of requesting payment at the end of the project, schedule
monthly or weekly payments for completed work. This is also
accomplished by requiring deposits for materials purchased during the
production process.
Overhead
Costs
Reducing
overhead costs, such as rent, utilities and interest, immediately
lowers a company's break-even point. When the break-even point is
lowered, the company can reach profitability sooner and experience
profitability over a larger range of sales. As sales increase, you
will be able to retain a greater percentage of sales dollars as
profit. One of the keys to managing overhead costs is to keep these
costs in balance with the sales level. Often overhead costs are spent
up front to generate the desired sales.
Management
Compensation
One
way to
reduce costs during an expansion phase is to reduce the owner's
compensation until the business is in a position to pay the owner
better. Compensation should match an owner's living expenses. Profit
returned to a business that is growing should be a good investment
for the owner.
Use
of Bar Code
Expanding
businesses need to carefully balance the costs associated with
increased business activity. The bar code system for inventory and
pricing can reduce costs in selling and controlling inventory. When
this system is used for checkouts, labor costs are reduced, as are
chances for error. Also, through its increased accuracy in
controlling inventory, the bar code system can decrease the number of
dollars tied up in inventory.
Leasing
Equipment
Leasing
is a way
of reducing costs if the equipment can be leased when you need it, or
if the time period you need the equipment is less than a normal
ownership period. Equity or net worth requirements may be less if
leasing is used to expand the business. The disadvantages of leasing
are that it does not allow net worth to build over time (unless it is
a lease-purchase arrangement) and it is usually more expensive than
an equal period of ownership.
Training
Employees
An
expanding
business may need to add employees who lack experience in its
business area and need training. There are several ways to reduce
training costs. One option is to look at federally funded programs
that assist in finding employees.
State
governments have other job-related training programs based on job
specifications. These programs can be researched by contacting local
employment agencies, state and federal departments of labor or
colleges. If employees need to learn a specific skill, the
Departments of Labor and Industry have programs that allow training
to be provided at a reduced cost to the employer. You can obtain
information on this program by contacting the relevant Departments of
Labor in your state.
Reducing
Costs by
Changing Business Organization
Expansion
At
times an
expansion can result in spreading existing fixed costs over a larger
sales volume. In this case, the decision to increase size is
justified. Whenever you have to increase fixed costs to attain higher
sales levels, investigate the proportion of the increase before
proceeding with growth plans.
An
example is
operating a wholesale business from a warehouse. Once the warehouse
is established, it becomes a fixed cost and you can increase sales by
adding a salespersona variable cost. The variable cost per unit of
sales (i.e., salespeople productivity) should remain constant in
order to result in a lower fixed cost per unit sold. Increased
variable costs can take away the benefit of lower fixed costs per
unit. This is true until the warehouse reaches its capacity to
function. One of the concerns here is that variable costs remain
constant. For example, if the additional salespeople cover a
territory farther from your base operation, there are additional
costs associated with travel and unproductive sales time. If the
variable costs deplete the advantage, then the decision to expand is
unprofitable.
Diversification
Diversification
is traditionally considered an option for business growth. One of the
major advantages of pursuing diversification is that it can balance
seasonal or yearly cycles in your business, or it can be used to
balance a multiyear cycle influenced by economic conditions. Usually
the area selected for diversification should be related to your
current business activity.
There
are two
types of diversification: vertical and horizontal. Vertical
diversification involves expanding either up or down the channel of
distribution. An example of vertical diversification is a
manufacturer who has been selling to independent wholesalers and then
starts his or her own wholesale operation. Horizontal diversification
involves adding other similar products or business lines. An example
of horizontal diversification is a business that manufactures and
sells ice and then starts bottling water. The bottled water is
related to its current activity and uses some of the same equipment,
thus reducing overhead costs. These two examples of diversification
provide a framework for identifying methods for creating additional
business.
Joint
Ventures
Joint
ventures
also can be a method for cutting expansion costs in production
processes, purchasing and sales. These relationships should be
established carefully so they benefit both parties and allow a way
for either party to end the relationship. The cost savings often
occur in the area of fixed overhead expenses, as these costs are now
shared.
Reducing
Costs by
Managing Risks
Risk
is always
associated with business activity. In a stable company risk is
manageable, but for a growing company risk can easily become
monumental. Unexpected occurrences may result in additional expenses
that increase the cash outflow. The following is a list of potential
risks and options to help reduce their impact on your business.
Lawsuits
Lawsuits
usually
can be avoided by complying with regulations or policies and taking
appropriate precaution not to harm others. Knowledge of federal and
state regulations is the responsibility of management. Two potential
areas for a lawsuit are relationships with employees and the
potential for physical harm to people or damage to their property. A
major cost with a lawsuit, in addition to legal fees, is the
possibility of bad publicity, which may take time, money and extra
effort to overcome. Discuss your concern over being sued with an
attorney. Talking to a business owner who has been sued may help
avoid problems as well as identify the courses of action to take if
you are sued. Even if all precautions have been taken, the risk of a
suit remains. Liability insurance is one means of reducing the
potential impact of the risk. At a time of growth, liability
insurance should be evaluated to determine if it is still adequate.
Patent
Infringements
Owners
of a
manufacturing or product development business should investigate the
possibility of obtaining patents for new products. Usually patent
infringement occurs because owners didn't realize the product was
patentable. If there already is a patent on the new product and the
patent owners become aware of your product when it is marketed, they
could force you to stop production and sue you for patent
infringement. Because of this potential, even if obtaining a patent
is not being considered, it is prudent to conduct a patent search to
assure that no one else has a patent for the product you plan to
produce. This can be done through patent attorneys, patent depository
libraries or computer data base systems.
Machine
Breakdowns
Most
business
activities use equipment that can break down unexpectedly. Not only
is there the possibility of additional repair costs but also there is
the likelihood of having to replace the equipment entirely. These
kinds of costs can be managed by implementing a preventive
maintenance program. The potential for breakdown is related to the
age of the equipment and the care it has been given. If you are
purchasing new equipment for a growth phase, the potential for
unforeseen repair costs should be reduced greatly. When expansion is
started with used equipment, the risk of the equipment breaking down
increases.
In
general,
money should be allotted for equipment repair and replacement;
depreciation dollars are normally accumulated for the purpose of
replacing the depreciated assets. However, in a case in which repair
costs will prolong the life of the asset, the dollars set aside for
depreciation may be used to cover repairs. This should apply only to
unusual repairs, not normal maintenance. In a business that has just
begun to grow, the depreciation account has not accumulated a
significant amount; therefore, a reasonable amount should be planned
for later financing.
Usually
manufacturers are concerned about this type of risk, but retail
businesses also have equipment that needs to be examined, including
cash registers, computers, air conditioners and delivery vehicles.
Supplier
Problems
During
an
expansion phase, relationships with new suppliers will be established
or existing relationships will be expanded, especially for volume
purchases. It may be a good policy to consider using diverse
suppliers. Dependence on one supplier can jeopardize your potential
sales volume if that supplier develops a problem and cannot produce.
As supplier relationships expand, consider formal written
relationships instead of relying on verbal understandings. These can
clarify any issues that later could cause problems. Pass on to
suppliers any obligations you have with your customers in areas in
which supplier performance can adversely affect your business.
Customer
Credit
In
a growing
business, establishing relationships with new customers and expanding
relationships with existing customers can create the potential for
non-collectible accounts. To obtain new customers, it may be tempting
to relax past credit policies. A careful determination of a new
customer's ability to pay should be considered and follow-up
collection procedures implemented. An amount should be set aside in
financial projections for bad debt expenses. This can be proportional
to the bad debt expense incurred in the past. However, the amount
could become higher as a portion of sales if credit terms are relaxed
to obtain increased sales.
Bank
Failure
Banks
are not
fail-safe. They have had and will continue to have an impact on
businesses, especially when they close. Banks financial statements
are available for public review. A good way to protect your company
from the effects of a bank failure is to obtain the bank's financial
statements and compare the total deposits to the number of
outstanding loans. Even if your company's bank is insured, should it
fail, it takes time for the insurance companies to release the cash
your company had in the bank. This could put a severe strain on the
cash flow of the business.
Physical
Damage
Even
though in
most cases physical risks are covered by insurance, whenever a
disaster strikes whether it is a fire, storm, flood, earthquake or
cyclone the disruption to the business will be greater than the
damage to the property. The major risk to a business is lost sales
because of (1) the business's inability to function and (2) the time
it takes to restructure the business.
Personnel
Problems
There
is
insurance to protect against most risks involving people, including
you or a key employee becoming disabled or dying. Even with the
insurance, there are additional costs associated with the loss. In
the case of either death or disablement, the business can be named as
the beneficiary, but the dollars recovered cannot repair all of the
damage caused by the business's inability to serve its customers'
needs.
Also
consider
the risk involved with losing company secrets. Do you have a system
to protect your trade secrets? Is there the potential for one of your
employees to share your business secrets? If you don't have
procedures to protect trade secrets, take the time to develop and
implement such policies.
Unions
If
your
operation is non-union, employees may vote to establish a union,
which is their legal right. Responsible management, however, is one
way of deterring employees from forming a union. Unions usually are
formed when wage levels or other working conditions are unacceptable
to the employees.
Unions
are not
necessarily to be avoided, a good union allied to good company
management can create an environment where all parties benefit.
Unknown
Laws
The
best way to
avoid costs in this category is to conduct business according to the
law. Attorneys or state and federal regulating agencies can help
review the requirements that pertain to your business. Trade
associations also can be helpful in staying abreast of developments.
Two areas particularly important to a business are labor and
environmental laws. Violating the law can result in costly fines and
penalties.
Tax
Requirements
Whenever
your
business is growing and changing, you should investigate the impact
taxes will have on the business, such as property, sales, payroll and
federal and state income taxes. Pay particular attention to sales tax
if your company is expanding into new geographic areas. Each state
has its own sales tax system, and states are cooperating in
collecting sales tax from out-of-state businesses.
Warranty
Claim
Risks
Manufacturing
companies have product warranty requirements. These requirements can
involve state and federal laws. A warranty claim on a single product
may not be devastating, but if a major flaw is detected in your
product and all the products sold are recalled, it can be quite a
challenge to overcome.
Documenting
Results
Your
Accounting
System
The
accounting
system of a growing business must change and adapt to new needs after
growth. Changes in accounting may be resisted by employees who are
comfortable with the existing system. Also, when accounting systems
change, it becomes more difficult to compare past trends with current
results. Further, a new or improved accounting system can cost time
and money to develop and implement, placing an additional strain on
limited resources. Despite these negatives, a growing business
usually needs additional management information from the accounting
system.
The
purpose of
most accounting systems is to provide management with information,
control and feedback. If your accounting system is used only for
providing information to the Taxation Department, it is not
fulfilling its total purpose. If business growth is occurring in
existing product or service lines, the current system will apply to
the new growth cycle. However, because the number of transactions
will increase, the accounting system should be evaluated to ensure
the data are accumulated in an efficient manner. This evaluation
should include whether certain types of transactions need to be
recategorized.
During
growth or
a change in the form of ownership, all previous accounting standards
need to be reconsidered to determine if changes are necessary.
Examples include
-
Cash-based
versus accrual accounting
-
Single- versus
double-entry accounting
-
Fiscal year
-
Form of
ownership
Cash-based
Versus
Accrual Accounting
If
you are using
the accrual accounting system, there probably is no need to change.
If you have been using the cash-based accounting system, perhaps the
accrual system should be considered. In cash accounting, transactions
are recorded as income or expenses when the cash has actually been
transferred. (For a retail business in which only cash is received on
the income side, the cash and accrual systems are the same.) In
accrual accounting, transactions are recorded when they occur or when
the goods or services are transferred. In this system, payment is
usually received after the product or service has been delivered. For
example, your business sold and delivered $10,000 worth of materials
on December 28 but was not paid until January 5. If you were
operating on a cashbased accounting system, you would record the
income in January; if you were on an accrual accounting system, you
would record the income in December. The accrual system can affect
your tax obligations. However, the main advantage of accrual
accounting is that it results in more meaningful information for
controlling business activities. This is true because expenses that
generate income are brought together in the same time period that the
income is reported.
Single-
Versus
Double-entry Accounting
Growth
might be
better managed with a double-entry system. Single-entry means that a
transaction is entered only once into your system. Double-entry
involves entering a transaction twice: first as a debit and then as a
credit. For example, in a double-entry system, the payment of an
invoice would be recorded as a materials purchased expense and as a
deduction from the cash account. Double entry accounting is more
accurate than single-entry accounting because each transaction is
entered as a balanced item with offsetting increases and decreases on
each side of the asset/liability or revenue/ expense ledger. Thus,
the resulting balances should be identical.
Form
of Ownership
The
accounting
system is slightly different for a sole proprietorship, a partnership
or a corporation. During a growth phase, you should perhaps consider
other forms of ownership and implement the accounting system that
matches that form.
Multiple
Accounting
Systems
Managers
need
guidance to make decisions. If you operate with a single or a simple
accounting system that produces a single income statement and balance
sheet, consider developing two or three separate accounting systems,
one for each area of your business, which can then be consolidated
into one income statement and balance sheet. The separate systems
will enable you to know what is happening.
This
is similar
to the concept of developing profit centers for a business. If you
operate a retail business, profit centers are divided into different
functional areas in your store, or, if you are a manufacturer, they
are based on your product lines. Accounting systems for each profit
center allow you to determine the profitability of each product. If
each product line or profit center category is generating a profit,
then the overall business will be profitable on a consolidated
accounting statement.
An
example is a
retail hardware store generating one income statement. Management
might benefit from dividing the business into functional areas such
as household, sports and tools, and developing income statements for
each of these areas. This information still must be consolidated into
one statement, but the individual statements provide information that
will help maximize profitability in each area. This system also works
for branch offices, which are often established to increase business
activity. Each branch office has its own operating system, then they
are pulled together into a consolidated system.
Accounting
systems are set up so that information flows from a large number of
entries to a final income statement and balance sheet. Income
statements allow trends to be tracked by listing a current month's
sales and expense amounts, current month's percentages, year-to-date
activity and year-to-date percentages. The current month percentage
is the expense amount for the month divided by sales. For example, if
sales were $100,000 and wages were $10,000, the percentage for wages
is 10 percent ($10,000 wages divided by $100,000 sales). This system
must be maintained, although categories may need to be added in a
growing business. The owner of a growing business should be able to
access reports that track the efficiency of the operation. If the
information is compiled appropriately, it will be readily available
at minimal cost.
For
example, on
an income statement for a restaurant, the cost of sales and labor are
separate items, including their dollar amounts and their percentage
relative to sales. Combine these and compare them over a time period.
If prepared food is purchased, the food cost per meal served will be
higher but the labor cost lower. This is particularly true in a
restaurant in which the labor and cost of food can be inversely
related. The important factor overall may be the combined percentages
of labor and material compared to sales. (However, be aware that
trends are not always accurate for comparison because they may
fluctuate seasonally. Compare trends from the same time frame each
year. This can be done by using a table or a graph to express the
comparison.)
Management
can
determine operational efficiency by several factors not measured in
dollars. Efficiency means that the business operation is maximizing
output levels for a given amount of time or resources. The management
information generated by the accounting system results in an accurate
measure of efficiency, but there is other information that can be
accumulated to measure efficiency. An example is the number of
prospect phone calls made over a certain time. By accumulating,
recording and tracking this information, the efficiency of the sales
staff can be calculated. In a manufacturing business, this can be the
number of hours it takes to perform certain tasks or the resulting
data collected from a statistical process control system.
Because
these
reports increase the fixed costs of your business, any report request
should be thought through carefully to ensure that the result is of
value to the user. With computerized data systems, it is very easy to
produce a lot of paper that isn't meaningful or usable for
management.
Computer
Applications
During
growth,
many business owners-managers believe a computer is necessary to
complete accounting needs for the business. This can be true, but
there are certain pitfalls to consider before selecting a system. If
you have a system, future growth may cause you to exceed the system's
current capacity, which will require a reevaluation of your system.
There
can be
costs associated with purchasing equipment and hardware, but perhaps
the most difficult cost to measure is the hidden cost involved with
implementing a computer system. Even though computers are supposed to
decrease the use of labor and add to the efficiency of the operation,
this often is not the case with a computer system. Before installing
a system, become familiar with how the system works and what it
produces by developing and implementing a manual or paper accounting
system. Once the manual system is completed and transferred to the
computer, you will know exactly what the system can and cannot
produce.
One
of the main
criteria for selecting a computer system is that the resulting
information be usable based upon the company's needs. There are
software packages specifically designed for accounting. Even though
they are expensive, they may cost less overall compared to developing
a system of your own. There are usually four issues that should be
considered in developing a computerized accounting system:
1. Design an accounting system programmed in a computer language.
2. Purchase a software spreadsheet package and program the
spreadsheet.
3. Purchase software specifically designed for accounting systems.
4. Purchase software designed for a specific accounting system for a
specific type of business.
All
of these
should be explored and reviewed carefully before you decide to
implement a particular system. Assistance should be sought not only
from computer and software vendors but also from accountants and
professionals with knowledge of accounting and computer applications.
It is sometimes tempting to purchase software that employees are
familiar with rather than to purchase a system tailored to the
business. This may work, but if the employees quit and the software
was not the best for the business, it could be challenging to keep
the system going.
In
addition to
considering the computer equipment and software, explore the
availability of printing options as they can affect the usefulness of
the information produced. Computer printers vary in printing speed,
quality of print, cost and page layout and dimensions. All of these
factors have an impact on the appearance of your output information.
Relationship
with
Your Accountants
Changes
in the
accounting system will cause you to reevaluate your relationship with
accountants. If you are doing your own accounting, you may need to
consider whether you should hire assistants or seek additional
training. Either way, a growing company requires more complex
accounting decisions. Growing companies can find themselves in a
position of having outgrown their accountant. If this happens, search
for a professional service that matches the level of your business
activities.
Accountants
can
design new systems for managing your business information. Be sure
you get what you need because, occasionally, accountants design
systems for tax purposes and have difficulty considering the broader
need for information management in your business. If you feel this
happening, rely on the accountant for your tax obligations but
consider seeking assistance from others in designing a system
consistent with your business needs. Remember, the accounting system
should be designed so your business grows into it. When you are
making changes, try to anticipate what will be happening in the
future to avoid the need for further change in your system. The
advantage of this is it will be easier to maintain a consistent
method of analyzing trends from year to year.
Tax
Consequences of
Growth
Growth
should
produce additional profit, which will result in an increasing tax
obligation. Several aspects of taxes affect growth. Tax reduction
often does not result in a decreased tax obligation but transfers
payment of the obligations to a future time. In a real sense, total
tax dollars paid over a long-term period are going to be fairly
constant. The idea usually is to reduce taxes now, then invest the
money so that as taxes become due more money is available.
One
of the
primary tasks of tax planning is contemplating profitability over the
next 10 to 20 years. If projections show profits will be low in the
first years and higher thereafter, consider transferring profit to
the first years. Should projections indicate higher taxes or profit
in the first years, arrange to pay tax now. Several factors influence
this decision. One possibility is to amortize expansion costs that
are unrelated to capital improvements. According to Taxation
Department guidelines, a capital improvement can be depreciated based
on a determined life span. This span usually involves physical assets
that wear out, as compared to expansion costs that can have a
positive effect on sales volume in the future. An example is any
expenditure used to develop a channel of distribution that is going
to be in existence for some time. This cost can be calculated and
amortized over a minimum of five years, thus reducing expenses in the
current year. A reduction in expenses means more profit, which means
paying more tax currently. When higher profits occur, amortization
will transfer more expense to that time period, resulting in lower
profit and taxes.
The
following
areas are among those that should be investigated to determine if
their costs, when associated with an expansion, can be amortized:
-
Training for
employees
-
Travel and
related expenses
-
Advertisement
related to the expansion
-
Surveys and
market research
-
Salaries of
those involved in the expansion
-
Organization
costs for the form of ownership
-
Research,
experimental and development costs
-
Agreements not
to compete
-
Cost of
acquiring leases
-
Cost of
commissions or finder fees
This
list is not
comprehensive.
Keep
in mind the
effect taxes will have on interest and depreciation. During the early
part of a business, interest and depreciation are usually high,
resulting in increased expenses and, thus, decreased profits. Later,
when the principal is paid down, interest is low and depreciation is
close to nonexistent, you will owe higher taxes, which will result in
a higher tax rate.
If
a change in
the ownership structure of the business is contemplated during a
growth period, be sure to consider the subsequent tax obligations. If
you own several separate businesses (with various situations of
profit and loss), it may be more cost effective to control them
through a parent holding company so tax losses in one business can be
balanced against tax owed in another business. Also, the form of
ownership, whether it is a sole proprietorship, a partnership or a
corporation, can have an impact on personal income taxes. In certain
business situations, the corporation can be a means of reducing taxes
and in other cases the sole proprietorship can result in lower income
or payroll taxes.
During
an
expansion, consider the current tax status of programs, such as
investment credit, which allows acceleration of deductions for
capital improvements. In the past, these accelerated methods were
called investment credit. This allows an additional deduction in the
current year which means lower profits and less tax. (Check with the
Taxation Department for specifics about the maximum allowance.) The
amount of the deduction is subtracted from the basis in order to
begin calculating depreciation on the capital assets. There are
specific guidelines on the taxable income limit, the carryover of an
allowable deduction and the original cost of the asset.
Investigate
the
impact taxes will have on growth by talking with tax accountants or
by studying tax information provided by the Taxation Department.
Conclusion
When
future
growth is anticipated by business owners, the excitement and
challenge often draw the owner's attention away from the financial
aspects of the business. Business history is full of examples of
businesses that accomplished growth but were unable to sustain their
new position, often because of lax attention to managing the finances
that support growth. Financial management needs to correspond to the
expansion activities being undertaken. Giving proper attention to
managing finances will enhance growth potential and sustain levels of
sales once they are obtained. Financial planning should be viewed not
as an obstacle but as a means of ensuring your success.
The
challenge of
a growing business should be carefully weighed against your personal
drive to achieve what you are attempting. It often seems the time and
effort it takes to achieve goals in business increase more than what
was originally anticipated. Part of a well-devised plan is to have
options open to compensate for possible areas that do not develop as
expected. To have these options identified so they can be implemented
immediately can often make the difference between success and
failure. To a great extent, growth potential is based on your ability
to know yourself. You must either have the personal abilities to
complete the growth, or you must know your limitations and have
resources available to cover them. Also, in some instances, business
owners rely too heavily on outside expertise or employees and are
misguided or misunderstand their ability to assist in obtaining
growth.
The
encouraging
side of growth is that many others have undertaken and achieved
growth successfully in business. There are many success stories in
which people have improved their income potential and their net
worth.
About the
author:
Dr. Lance Chambers is a Futurist, Strategic Planner and Engineer by
profession and is a well regarded data analysis expert. He has run his
own consulting firm and has worked in private industry and government
in his earlier working life. Today he develops web pages for the net
and offers his expertise free of charge on-line.
|